Wednesday, July 27, 2022
HomeMutual FundMonetary Planning for Retirement vs. Monetary Planning after Retirement

Monetary Planning for Retirement vs. Monetary Planning after Retirement


There’s a BIG distinction between monetary planning for retirement (accumulation section) and monetary planning throughout retirement (decumulation section).

Let’s take a look at what I imply. On this put up, I’ll restrict the dialogue to investments.

Monetary Planning for Retirement (Accumulation Section)

Throughout this section, you are attempting to accumulating funds for retirement. Fairly clearly, this section is BEFORE retirement.

  1. You don’t withdraw out of your portfolio.
  2. Volatility might be your buddy.
  3. Rupee price averaging (via SIPs or common investing) works in your favour, if markets transfer up over the long run.
  4. You don’t thoughts decrease asset costs (or market corrections) within the interim as long as issues get tremendous by the point you retire.

Monetary Planning Throughout Retirement (Decumulation Section)

Throughout retirement (decumulation section), it’s a must to depend on your portfolio on your revenue.

  1. You must withdraw out of your portfolio to satisfy your bills.
  2. There aren’t any additional contemporary investments.
  3. Volatility could be a critical enemy.
  4. You’re topic to Sequence of Returns Danger. We’ll come to it later.
  5. Rupee price averaging can go towards you. Once more, we are going to come to it later.
  6. Sharp market corrections through the early a part of your retirement can destroy you financially.

What’s Sequence of Returns Danger?

It’s worthwhile to fear not nearly long-term common returns.

It’s worthwhile to fear concerning the sequence of returns too.

Since you might be withdrawing from the portfolio on the time market goes down, the portfolio could deplete fairly rapidly.  And this offers rise to a different downside.

In case your portfolio is depleted past restore, there will not be a lot left when the nice sequence of returns comes round.

Reliance on long-term common returns is ok if you end up within the accumulation section. Throughout retirement, don’t undermine the significance of sequence of returns.


Let’s attempt to perceive with the assistance of an instance.

Let’s assume you will have simply retired on the age of 60.

  1. You’ve deliberate for an additional 30 years till the age of 90. No one is aware of how lengthy they’ll reside however you’ll be able to add 10-15 years to the age your grandparents/nice grandparents handed away to start.
  2. You want Rs 50,000 per 30 days. You have to Rs 6 lacs each year.
  3. There is no such thing as a inflation. 0% inflation. Illogical however please play alongside.
  4. You reside in tax-free society. There aren’t any taxes.

With these assumptions, you have to Rs. 50,000 X 12 months X 30 years = Rs 1.8 crores to final your retirement. I’ve assumed 0% return in your portfolio.

Let’s tinker round with the return assumption.

Let’s now assume there is only one asset class, equities, that has given long-term returns of 10% each year (and can proceed to take action). Illogical once more. Play alongside.

You withdraw out of your corpus initially of the yr to supply for the remainder of the yr.

With these assumptions (0% inflation, 10% return and withdrawal initially of the yr), you want Rs 62.2 lacs on your retirement (down from Rs 1.8 crores at 0% return assumption).

State of affairs 1 (Fixed returns of 10% p.a. yearly)

Retirement Planning for retirement 1

Seems good, doesn’t it? All the pieces is hunky-dory.

Yearly, you earn a return of 10% p.a. Your corpus is over within the 90th yr.

Aren’t we ignoring one thing?

Do you actually anticipate to earn 10% in yearly?

In actual life, returns aren’t fixed. Though long-term common could also be round 10%, it doesn’t imply you’ll earn 10% yearly.

What in case you are unfortunate and retire through the dangerous patch in markets?

You don’t management it, do you?

Within the following instance, I’ve chosen returns for just a few years in order that long-term common return that you just earn is 10% p.a. however the preliminary few years are dangerous for markets.

State of affairs 2 (Non-constant returns, Lengthy-term common intact)

Retirement Planning for retirement 2

Your portfolio is depleted within the 18th yr.  What do you do for the remaining 12 years?

Please perceive I’ve chosen the sequence of returns to exhibit my level. For one more sequence of returns, your portfolio could have lasted for extra or fewer variety of years. With a beneficial sequence of returns, you might even be taking a look at leaving an property on your heirs.

For example, for those who swap the returns for 1st and seventh years (-10% and 58%), you’ll find yourself with Rs 1.1 crores on the finish of 90 years.

What does this let you know?

If you happen to face adversarial market circumstances within the earlier years, your portfolio could not final the deliberate time period.

Why did this occur?

This occurred since you had been withdrawing from the corpus on the identical time.

Rupee price averaging works within the reverse route. You must REDEEM MORE models at LOWER costs to keep up the extent of revenue. That’s why SWP from fairness funds is a nasty concept.

Subsequently, your losses grew to become everlasting.

By the point good sequence of returns got here round, the injury had already been accomplished.

For example, below fixed returns situation, you had been to be left with Rs 61.5 lacs on the finish of two years. Within the situation we thought of, you might be left with solely Rs 42.3 lacs. Over 30% much less.

Your withdrawal price has shot up sharply.

If you happen to evaluate, within the third yr, you might be withdrawing ~10% of your portfolio in fixed returns situation whereas within the second case, you withdraw nearly 15% of your portfolio.


Do notice I thought of 0% inflation. With a constructive inflation, the state of affairs would have been even worse.

What are you able to do to protect towards Sequence of Returns?

Clearly, you don’t management the sequence of returns. Nevertheless, right here are some things you’ll be able to construct into your retirement planning.

  1. Goal a a lot larger corpus that may face up to sharp losses. Whereas calculating retirement corpus, be conservative concerning the price of inflation (larger is best) and return expectation (decrease is best).
  2. Plan for a higher variety of years (40 as a substitute of 30).
  3. Cut back withdrawals for just a few years. Fairly impractical.
  4. Work part-time throughout retirement. If you happen to keep away from withdrawals (or cut back withdrawals) out of your portfolio even for just a few years, it’s going to have a critical impression on the longevity of your portfolio.

For example, persevering with with the identical non-constant returns situation however no withdrawals for the primary two years,

State of affairs 3 (Non-constant returns, Lengthy-term common intact, No withdrawals for the primary two years)

Retirement Planning financial planning for retirement 3

You may see, by not any withdrawals for the primary two years, you might be left with a pleasant change of Rs 67 lacs on the finish of 30 years. You averted withdrawing within the dangerous years. Subsequently, your corpus was nonetheless round when the nice set of returns got here.

  1. You may assessment your portfolio at common intervals. If you happen to suppose you might be struggling, it might be time to select a part-time job to cut back withdrawals from the portfolio. Could also be simpler to return to work throughout early a part of retirement.
  2. Use asset allocation methods to stability between development (inflation safety) and revenue portion of your portfolios and cut back volatility on the identical time. Very subjective.
  3. Buy annuity on the proper time to handle longevity danger.

I’ve mentioned concerning the sequence of returns danger and how one can cut back such danger intimately in this put up.

Would issues have been any totally different if this occurred throughout Accumulation Section?

If you happen to encountered a nasty sequence of returns whereas saving for retirement, how would you will have fared?

Let’s assume you make investments Rs 6 lacs on the primary day of yearly for 30 years.

At fixed returns of 10% each year, you’ll find yourself with Rs 10.8 crores.

For non-constant returns as proven earlier, you’ll find yourself with Rs 12.47 crores.

Sure, you find yourself with a bigger corpus.

This occurred since you earned the upper returns on a a lot larger corpus. I’ve mentioned an analogous case in one other put up.

Do notice this won’t at all times occur. That is for a particular sequence of returns. The outcomes could reverse for an additional sequence particularly if poor returns come in the direction of the top of the buildup section.

Subsequently, volatility could be a buddy through the accumulation section (there isn’t a assure although). Since you might be nonetheless contributing, your get higher variety of models through the downturn. This rewards you when the markets flip for the nice later.

Aside from that, you can also make changes alongside the best way throughout accumulation. For example, you’ll be able to enhance investments for those who really feel you’ll wrestle to succeed in the goal retirement corpus.

No such luxurious throughout retirement (decumulation section).

This put up was first printed on June 17, 2017 and has been up to date since.




Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments